Sign up for email updates!

Don't miss out on what matters. Sign up for email updates!

Stay informed! Sign up for e-mail updates:

Saturday, February 22, 2020

A Note on Excess Government Compensation

One of the problems with big government is that it slows down the growth in the very tax base that pays for that same big governments. Here is an example of how this "boomerang" effect works.


The legislature has now spent a week with Governor Gordon's budget. We will take a close look at it in a day or two; for now, here is a statistical note on why it is essential to reduce the size of government. 

As I have reported on many occasions, Wyoming has the nation's largest government workforce - our Government Employment Ratio is the highest of all 50 states - and the reason is not that we are a rural state. It is entirely of our own doing: we have a big workforce because we ask government to do things for us that could be done better by the private sector. 

Analytically, it is not difficult to nail down what we need to do to shrink government; the problem is on the political side where the will to execute the right kind of reforms is still too weak. While a large segment of our legislature keeps resisting reform, many of them are also aware that our economy is not growing very well. Their concerns, however, are motivated more by the lack of tax revenue than by anything else.

It is true, though, that a large government sector is related to slow economic growth. Government stifles growth in four ways: by imposing costly taxes, fees and charges that drain the private sector of money; by piling up costly regulations in the way of businesses and families going about their lives; by discouraging entrepreneurship and career development through economic redistribution; and by draining the workforce in local communities by means of tax-paid jobs.

The last point is often under-estimated. Government is not open to competition; regardless what we hear about how government cannot keep talent because it can't pay enough, the fact of the matter is that those are rare exceptions in highly specialized areas. A large majority of the roughly 60,000 state and local government employees in Wyoming are not exposed to private competition. The reason is either that there basically are no private employers (teachers) or that government artificially - by virtue of tax funding - can offer so much better employment conditions that private-sector employers do not stand a chance.

It is, in fact, easy to demonstrate that government employees in general are overpaid and thereby to show why the private sector is a better source of economic growth. We measure the value of the economic contribution of an industry by its share of our GDP. For example, in 2018 the 9,600 private-sector employees in Uinta County produced a total economic value of $$776.9 million, or $80,937 per employee. That same year, the 2,258 government employees in that same county produced $150,6 million in economic value, for an average of $66,704. 

In other words, in Uinta the contribution from the average government employee was 82 cents to the dollar in the private sector. 

In a sound economy this difference would be coupled with a similar difference in employee compensation (which includes wages and salaries as well as benefits). The average government job would pay 82 percent of the average private-sector job. That is not the case though:  in 2018 the average government worker in Uinta County made $1.57 for every $1.00 made by the average private-sector worker. 

In some counties government workers contribute more, on average, to the economy than private-sector workers do. There is a specific reason for this that we will get back to in a moment; first, let Figure 1 compare the pay difference (blue line) with the value difference (grey). In every single county, the difference in pay vastly exceeds the difference in value contribution:

Figure 1
Source of raw data: Bureau of Economic Analysis

In eleven counties government jobs contribute more, on average, to the economy than do private-sector jobs. Despite this, in every one of those counties, the pay disparity between government and private jobs vastly exceeds the value disparity: even when government employees contribute more to the economy, they are still over-paid.

That said, the over-payment problem in these eleven counties is not as bad as it is in counties where government workers contribute less to the economy than private-sector workers do. Figure 2 reports the value disparity from Figure 1 (grey) and the ratio between pay and value disparities (red). The higher the ratio is (red), the more over-paid are government workers:

Figure 2

Source of raw dataBureau of Economic Analysis

Why, then, are there counties where government workers contribute more to the economy than private-sector workers? As Table 1 reports, the reason is simple: private-sector jobs pay poorly (CoE Pr.) on those counties. In fact, in counties with a value disparity above 1 (government jobs contribute more than private-sector jobs) the average private-sector job pays $29,454 in total compensation, while in counties where the private sector produces a higher per-employee value, the average compensation is $40,266:

Table 1
Source of raw data: Bureau of Economic Analysis

CoE Pr. Value
Sheridan     29,460 1.57
Johnson     20,282 1.54
Teton     36,265 1.42
Park     29,288 1.35
Laramie     37,135 1.26
Converse     26,582 1.15
Crook     30,241 1.14
Lincoln     32,347 1.11
Niobrara     17,541 1.09
Washakie     34,578 1.09
Albany     30,280 1.08
Weston     27,566 0.98
Big Horn     30,019 0.97
Hot Springs     27,315 0.94
Goshen     25,696 0.89
Uinta     36,959 0.82
Natrona     44,725 0.82
Carbon     47,436 0.59
Sweetwater     62,434 0.54
Converse     45,279 0.51
Campbell     54,613 0.44
Platte     37,877 0.44
Sublette     43,267 0.42

Since government does not compensate their workers based on market rates, economic growth is weaker when government is big. Excess compensation means, so to speak, that economic value is lost; think of it as heating your house with the windows open. That is not to say that government jobs don't add value - they do - but the lack of a market mechanism for matching pay with value leads to more "hot air" being lost as government grows.

Wyoming is in desperate need of better paying private-sector jobs. Those jobs do not come from government subsidies, tax breaks and other forms of corporate welfare. They come from deregulation, lower and - yes - predictable taxes, and a small, efficient and non-invasive government sector. With a larger private sector and a smaller government, we will produce more economic value and thereby a broader tax base. With that tax base we can sustainably fund the small government we need, starting with the essentials: law enforcement, fire and rescue and infrastructure. 

No comments:

Post a Comment